Megaprojects The Role Of The Public Germanys Embattled Stuttgart 21 Rail Project Case Study Analysis


Home >> Chicago Booth >> Megaprojects The Role Of The Public Germanys Embattled Stuttgart 21 Rail Project >>

Megaprojects The Role Of The Public Germanys Embattled Stuttgart 21 Rail Project Case Study Solution

Background and Facts

Megaprojects The Role Of The Public Germanys Embattled Stuttgart 21 Rail Project a workplace materials retailer for little and medium sized companies has recently been associated with planning for a merging with its competitor Residence Deport, which has actually influenced efficiency degrees in departmentswith the elderly supervisor involved in lawful issues put forth by the government Trade Payment. With the Advertising and marketing Head advancing the news of his departure from the business in one year, Jeannie Lewis, the existing head of operations has actually been asked to take the duty in the future. With obstacles in the type of a potential cultural change and reduced staff member spirits, the organization is in need of a total reengineering effort at the advertising and marketing department.

Problem Declaration
Porter's 5 Forces Analysis
The possible social adjustment at the advertising and marketing department of Megaprojects The Role Of The Public Germanys Embattled Stuttgart 21 Rail Project is raising unpredictability in the workplace resulting in various difficulties for the Jeannie Lewis that would be replacing the head of the department in one year. nalysis

PEST analysis

Political Factors: Political factors play a significant duty in influencing tactical decisions since Stapes Inc. needed to abandon its strategies of combining with Office Deport after the Federal Profession Compensation's intervention in the process. Given the fact that the shop has a worldwide existence with branches in UK, U.S.A., Canada and also Germany, political factors in each of these countries might have the ability to impact efficiency or strategic goals. Federal Profession Commission's antitrust match versus the merger took up important time of the organization's senior management suggesting that 'political' factors can have serious implications for an international service.

Economic Factors: Economic factors such as the development of small companies in the global scenario recommend that Megaprojects The Role Of The Public Germanys Embattled Stuttgart 21 Rail Project is growing in an environment where there is prospective development of businesses. Reality that store customers are primarily looking for office materials for house offices suggests that the market has a rising trend of entrepreneurs and also house based organisations.

Social factors: Social trends in the economic climate reveal that customers are trying to find convenience along with eye-catching prices. Marketing research demonstrates how the consumer for Megaprojects The Role Of The Public Germanys Embattled Stuttgart 21 Rail Project lacks awareness about locating options which can supply a combination of comfort and also inexpensive.

Technical factors: Modern technology plays a crucial role in Megaprojects The Role Of The Public Germanys Embattled Stuttgart 21 Rail Project's business strategy particularly as the company is piloting Innovation facilities which would supply technology sales and also assistance in the type of memory upgrades, peripheral setups. (Summary of BUG in appendix 2).

OB Issues as well as Effects.

Numerous underlying Business Actions problems can be seen in Megaprojects The Role Of The Public Germanys Embattled Stuttgart 21 Rail Project's case as highlighted in this area.

Worries regarding social modification: There is concern about a social adjustment that would certainly occur as soon as Todd Krasnow leaves from his placement as the Executive Vice Head Of State of Advertising with most of the staff members currently showing unhappiness over this possible action. This expected adjustment has produced tension in the work environment which has actually been coupled with the previous stress and anxiety of preparing the company for a potential merger with Home Deport.
Pest Analysis
Stressful Job Setting for Newcomers: There is shortage of workers that can match the stressful environment of a hectic organization. Not just does this result in trouble in discovering the ideal individuals, it puts tension on new hires as can not withstand the speed and also pressure that the organization expects them to birth.

Twin Coverage Lines: Newbies locate this organizational culture cumbersome and tough to handle specifically as populated line connections are indicated to be weak generally and also unbiased setting as well as performance examination is still done by the solid line supervisor. This means that newbies can shed clarity concerning their corresponding roles and objectives specifically as populated line reporting does not maintain them in straight interaction with the solid line supervisors.

Resentment From Cross Departmental Hiring: Krasnow's choice to make Lewis his follower instead of Bridget Coles although it had been hypothesized that the last would certainly take Krasnow's placement came as a strike to her morale. Lewis might have been capable and ideal for the task however the reality that Kransnow's departure would certainly make Coles a straight record to Lewis might have been the reason for Coles' resignation from services.

Fear & Task Insecurity: Fear and insecurity can be determined as two significant problems that Lewis would be handling particularly as the merging has actually now be terminated as well as two senior execs of the advertising department would certainly be leaving. The whole responsibility of the division would certainly be falling on Lewis's shoulders who would not simply supervise of brining concerning a cultural change however would certainly likewise need to verify herself in her new function.

Inappropriate Administration Style of Leader: Lewis's administration design and also its conflict with the marketing division's role can also be viewed as an OB challenge specifically as she has actually been used to managing problems in the operations department where personnel are instructed to concentrate on procedures as well as obtain them right. The marketing division on the other hand can be seen as a group of individuals who are made use of to being nurtured by Krasnow that focused much more on result than processes.

Interdepartmental Disputes: Interdepartmental differences in between three divisions, advertising, merchandizing and procedures specifically over the appropriation of the advertising mix can be identified as one more OB worry. Although the advertising division does not share the exact same vision as the other two departments relating to the aloocation of the advertising mix twoards promotions as well as advertsing, the merchandizing as well as procedures divisions do not concur over the marketing mix allowance amongst each other either.

Fragmentation in Advertising And Marketing Division: Disintegration between the marketing and advertising divisions can be determined as one more OB issue which could require additional attention. The truth that the advertising and marketing sections in the marketing division are separated is protecting against both divisions from acquiring from each various other's experience and also experience. Assimilation of marketing with merchandising and also procedures would certainly come to be harder if the marketing division itself is broken down which can be an additional prospective OB concern.

Megaprojects The Role Of The Public Germanys Embattled Stuttgart 21 Rail Project Analysis

Different concepts have actually been made use of to discuss the conditions to get further quality regarding the situation at hand.
Swot Analysis
McGregor's Concept X & Y: According to Douglas McGregor's Concept X, most supervisors think that staffs are easy as well as careless, have little aspiration and stand up to adjustment. The difficult variation of this theory highlighted browbeating, tight controls, dangers as well as penalties. Gradually it produces reduced productivity, refined sabotage and competition (Bargain, 2003). The scenario at Megaprojects The Role Of The Public Germanys Embattled Stuttgart 21 Rail Project is not totally adhering to Theory X, it can be seen that brand-new hires are locating this setting rather difficult which may eventually lead to a higher inclination of the administration in the direction of Theory X. According to McGregor's advocated view, which he called Concept Y, the crucial task of the monitoring is to prepare organizational conditions to ensure that individuals can accomplish their own goals best by directing their efforts in the direction of business rewards. If individuals find no fulfillment in their work, the management would certainly have little option however to rely on theory X and also external control (Bargain, 2003). Even while examining Lewis's administration style, theory X may have been suitable in the operations division somewhat yet the Advertising and marketing department would certainly require reliance on Theory Y so as to get the creativity as well as creativity from the teams.

Tuckman's Team effort Concept: As far as Lewis's issue concerning bringing harmony between the marketing and advertising department is worried, this would at first result in conflict as reviewed by Bruce Tuckman in his 'Teamwork Theory'. (Tuckman, 1965). As per Tuckman's theory received appendix 3, throughout the first stage of team growth, people might not bond, as they are hectic finding their place in the team. By incorporating the advertising and marketing department's work, there may coincide initial separate which can cause the 2nd stage of 'storming' where the teams challenge one another. It is only throughout the 3rd stage or 'norming' when they would certainly come together to share concepts before the team can bring around harmony in the 4th phase 'executing'.

When people are presented with adjustment, they enter phase one as well as so there may be emotions like sadness, uncertainty, stress, anger, anxiety, rejection and disorientation.The scenario at the advertising department of Megaprojects The Role Of The Public Germanys Embattled Stuttgart 21 Rail Project is comparable so Lewis can get comfy with the idea that it is not amazing behavior. It is throughout this phase that Lewis will have to offer guidance to the department so that they can discover a sense of direction. It can be seen exactly how Krasnow has already made this transition less complicated by making Lewis obtain included in the department a year before his real departure.
Vrio Analysis
Maslow's Requirement pecking order: The OB issue pertaining to instability at the office has been activated firstly by the change in monitoring and also secondly by the truth that the merger will no longer be started. Abraham Maslow in his Theory of 'Requirements Hierarchy' (appendix 5) has reviews the significance of 'security requires as being a lower degree demand of a human for setting off inspiration. As seen in the pyramid cooperated appendix 3, we can see just how 'the need to feel safe and also unharmed' goes to the second level of needs. Before an employee can be made to create psychologically, he requires to have his 'Physical 'as well as 'Security' requires met. This indicates that unless the employees are made to really feel safe and secure regarding their current employment status in Megaprojects The Role Of The Public Germanys Embattled Stuttgart 21 Rail Project they may not get to 'Self-Fulfillment'. (King, 2009).

SWOT Analysis for Megaprojects The Role Of The Public Germanys Embattled Stuttgart 21 Rail Project Case Study

Effects of Analysis.

The OB analysis has actually taken a look at various concepts to comprehend exactly how to manage the existing situation available. The complying with 3 alternatives have actually been suggested to help Lewis handle the business obstacles in the advertising and marketing division. Each of these choices has actually been proposed for easing the change needed to bring the advertising and marketing division in accordance with the demands of the marketplace as well as for making the social adjustment that would comply with as soon as the present leader leaves.

Assimilation of marketing and advertising functions. Dividing Adverting and Manufacturing functions. Combination of Advertising with Workflow.

Assessment of Alternatives.

Combination of Marketing & Advertising Functions: The in-house marketing company of Megaprojects The Role Of The Public Germanys Embattled Stuttgart 21 Rail Project is currently toughness for the organization in regards to saving up on overheads associated with advertising and promo. Since no brand-new employment has been done after Bridget Cole's departure with the coverage line being directly appointed to Krasnow for the marketing feature, this is a desirable chance for integrating the marketing and advertising functions. Judith Shapiro who has earlier been interviewed by Lewis during the earlier merging days has know-how in business-to-business advertising along with company and retail advertising and marketing experience. As soon as Krasnow leaves, Lewis can hire Shapiro as an EVP for advertising to deal with both advertising and marketing functions.

The benefit of this strategy is that it will certainly incorporate the two features while reducing the requirement for employing an extra resource for advertising and marketing. Along with this, Lewis would be heading the advertising division as well as all the same her replacement would be required for the existing duty that she is carrying out. The drawback of this alternative is that outside hiring may produce resentment from interior workers that may be considering the position of EVP after Lewis takes control of Krasnow's placement.

Separating Adverting as well as Manufacturing: Offered the competitive pressures and also excellent quality work needed from the advertising agency, it is suggested that Lewis ought to allow the production system to be a different feature from the marketing system. Because the majority of advertising agencies had these 2 functions as separate units, it makes even more feeling to adhere to the norm. Both features may be able to focus on their core turns on a lot more efficiently. The negative aspect of this strategy would certainly be that additional prices would certainly have to be borne for establishing up different manufacturing functions. A production head may have to be employed which might boost expenses for the company.

Assimilation of Advertising And Marketing with Operations: Given that Lewis is already caring for the advertising as well as operations divisions concurrently; it makes good sense to incorporate the two functions since she has actually been successfully looking after both ends. The reality that both departments already have significant differences over allotment of resources suggests that this integration may have the ability to cause consistency particularly as Lewis would be heading both ends.However there are various disadvantages of this move particularly as it would put way too much burden over Lewis's shoulders. The reality that Lewis needs to adjust her monitoring style for the advertising and marketing department suggests that these 2 departments would be culturally varied. Lewis may not be able to apply one kind of leadership style to both departments which can result in inefficiency in either one of the two features.


An assessment of the three choices suggests that assimilation of marketing as well as operations would certainly not be a viable action due to the vast distinctions between the two divisions despite the truth that presently Lewis is taking care of both. While separation of the production feature may have been a desirable relocation for the advertising and marketing department, the truth that it would suggest positioning a 3rd function under Lewis's wing suggests this need to be stayed clear of.

Action Strategy.
Lewis will take over the duty of EVP Marketing after Krasnow leaves.

Marketing and advertising functions would certainly be combined.

Judith Shapiro will certainly be worked with to take Lewis's area as SVP of marketing and advertising.

Manufacturing function will certainly continue to be component of advertising and marketing under advertising and marketing feature.

Lewis will certainly separate herself from procedures.

An autonomous leadership design with worker empowerment will certainly be used in marketing division.

Open up door policy and also focus on cross departmental interaction will be targeted at getting rid of disharmony.

Backup strategy.

If the integration does not work out as planned, a backup strategy would comply with which would separate the manufacturing feature from the advertising and marketing function to lower the load on the SVP of advertising and marketing. In case Judith Shapiro does not get employed, Lewis will be heading the marketing division without an SVP. In that case the manufacturing function will certainly be divided by placing it under an SVP production.