Renova Toilet Paper Escaping The Commoditization Trap Abridged Case Study Solution


Home >> Chicago Booth >> Renova Toilet Paper Escaping The Commoditization Trap Abridged >>

Renova Toilet Paper Escaping The Commoditization Trap Abridged Case Study Solution

Background and Facts

Renova Toilet Paper Escaping The Commoditization Trap Abridged an office supplies seller for little as well as medium sized organisations has actually just recently been involved in planning for a merging with its competitor Residence Deport, which has actually influenced performance degrees in departmentswith the elderly supervisor associated with lawful complications presented by the federal Trade Compensation. With the Advertising Head advancing the information of his separation from the business in one year, Jeannie Lewis, the current head of operations has been asked to take the function in the future. With obstacles in the kind of a possible social change and low staff member spirits, the organization is in need of a full reengineering effort at the advertising department.

Problem Statement
Porter's 5 Forces Analysis
The possible cultural change at the advertising department of Renova Toilet Paper Escaping The Commoditization Trap Abridged is raising uncertainty in the workplace resulting in different difficulties for the Jeannie Lewis who would be replacing the head of the department in one year. nalysis

PEST analysis

Political Factors: Political factors play a major role in impacting strategic decisions considering that Stapes Inc. had to abandon its strategies of merging with Workplace Deport after the Federal Trade Commission's treatment at the same time. Offered the reality that the store has a worldwide presence with branches in UK, USA, Canada as well as Germany, political consider each of these nations may have the ability to affect efficiency or critical objectives. Federal Profession Commission's antitrust suit against the merging used up beneficial time of the organization's senior monitoring recommending that 'political' factors can have severe effects for a worldwide service.

Economic Factors: Economic factors such as the appearance of small companies in the global situation suggest that Renova Toilet Paper Escaping The Commoditization Trap Abridged is thriving in an environment where there is possible development of companies. In addition to this, reality that store customers are mostly seeking office products for home offices suggests that the market has a climbing fad of business owners and online companies.

Social factors: Social fads in the economic climate reveal that consumers are seeking convenience in addition to attractive rates. Market research shows how the consumer for Renova Toilet Paper Escaping The Commoditization Trap Abridged lacks understanding concerning discovering services which can provide a combination of convenience and also affordable.

Technological factors: Modern technology plays a crucial function in Renova Toilet Paper Escaping The Commoditization Trap Abridged's company approach particularly as the organization is piloting Modern technology facilities which would supply technology sales and also support in the form of memory upgrades, peripheral installations. (Summary of PEST in appendix 2).

OB Issues as well as Symptoms.

A number of underlying Organizational Actions problems can be seen in Renova Toilet Paper Escaping The Commoditization Trap Abridged's case as highlighted in this area.

Worries regarding social change: There is worry concerning a social modification that would happen as soon as Todd Krasnow leaves from his position as the Executive Vice President of Advertising with most of the staff members currently showing discontent over this potential relocation. This predicted modification has actually created stress in the office which has actually been coupled with the past stress of preparing the firm for a potential merger with House Deport.
Pest Analysis
Stressful Job Environment for Newcomers: There is lack of personnel that can match the difficult environment of a fast-paced company. Not only does this bring about problem in locating the ideal people, it puts tension on brand-new hires as can not stand up to the rate as well as pressure that the company anticipates them to bear.

Double Coverage Lines: Novices locate this organizational culture troublesome and also challenging to deal with especially as dotted line partnerships are indicated to be weaker as a whole and also objective setting and efficiency examination is still done by the solid line manager. This indicates that beginners could shed clearness regarding their particular functions as well as goals specifically as populated line reporting does not maintain them in straight interaction with the strong line managers.

Resentment From Cross Departmental Hiring: Krasnow's choice to make Lewis his successor rather than Bridget Coles although it had actually been guessed that the last would take Krasnow's setting came as an impact to her morale. Lewis may have been qualified and ideal for the job however the fact that Kransnow's departure would make Coles a direct report to Lewis may have been the factor for Coles' resignation from services.

Anxiety & Work Insecurity: Anxiety as well as insecurity can be recognized as 2 significant problems that Lewis would certainly be dealing with specifically as the merging has now be terminated and two elderly execs of the advertising department would certainly be leaving. The entire obligation of the department would certainly be falling on Lewis's shoulders who would certainly not just be in charge of brining regarding a cultural modification yet would likewise need to verify herself in her new duty.

Inappropriate Management Design of Leader: Lewis's administration style and also its incompatibility with the advertising department's function can also be viewed as an OB challenge particularly as she has actually been made use of to handling issues in the procedures department where employees are instructed to concentrate on processes and get them right. The advertising department on the other hand can be viewed as a group of individuals who are made use of to being nurtured by Krasnow that focused much more on result than processes.

Interdepartmental Arguments: Interdepartmental differences between three departments, advertising, merchandizing and operations specifically over the appropriation of the advertising mix can be determined as one more OB concern. Although the advertising department does not share the very same vision as the various other two divisions relating to the aloocation of the marketing mix twoards promos and advertsing, the merchandizing as well as operations divisions do not agree over the advertising mix allocation amongst each other either.

Disintegration in Advertising Division: Disintegration in between the advertising and marketing divisions can be identified as one more OB concern which can need additional attention. The fact that the advertising and marketing sections in the marketing department are detached is preventing both divisions from obtaining from each various other's experience and proficiency. Assimilation of advertising and marketing with retailing and also operations would end up being more difficult if the advertising division itself is degenerated which can be another prospective OB concern.

Renova Toilet Paper Escaping The Commoditization Trap Abridged Analysis

Numerous theories have actually been made use of to explain the conditions to obtain more clearness regarding the circumstance at hand.
Swot Analysis
McGregor's Theory X & Y: According to Douglas McGregor's Theory X, most managers think that staffs are passive as well as lazy, have little passion and resist adjustment. The difficult variation of this theory emphasized browbeating, tight controls, hazards and punishments. In time it produces low efficiency, refined sabotage as well as rivalry (Bargain, 2003). The scenario at Renova Toilet Paper Escaping The Commoditization Trap Abridged is not completely complying with Concept X, it can be seen that brand-new hires are finding this environment rather difficult which may eventually lead to a higher disposition of the administration towards Concept X. According to McGregor's promoted view, which he called Concept Y, the necessary task of the monitoring is to prepare business problems so that individuals can achieve their very own goals best by directing their initiatives in the direction of organizational incentives. If individuals locate no contentment in their work, the monitoring would certainly have little selection however to rely upon concept X and outside control (Deal, 2003). Even while analyzing Lewis's monitoring style, concept X may have appropriated in the procedures division to some extent yet the Advertising division would certainly call for dependence on Theory Y in order to get the creative thinking and also originality from the teams.

Tuckman's Synergy Concept: As far as Lewis's issue regarding bringing consistency in between the marketing and marketing department is worried, this would originally lead to conflict as gone over by Bruce Tuckman in his 'Teamwork Concept'. By integrating the advertising and marketing and also advertising and marketing division's job, there may be the very same preliminary detach which can lead to the 2nd phase of 'storming' where the groups test one another.

When people are provided with adjustment, they get in stage one and so there might be emotions like despair, unpredictability, stress, temper, fear, denial and also disorientation.The circumstance at the advertising and marketing division of Renova Toilet Paper Escaping The Commoditization Trap Abridged is similar so Lewis can obtain comfortable with the suggestion that it is not remarkable habits. It is throughout this phase that Lewis will certainly have to give support to the division so that they can locate a feeling of instructions. It can be seen how Krasnow has currently made this change less complicated by making Lewis get included in the department a year prior to his actual separation.
Vrio Analysis
Maslow's Need pecking order: The OB concern related to insecurity at the work environment has been triggered first of all by the change in administration as well as second of all by the truth that the merger will certainly no longer be launched. Abraham Maslow in his Theory of 'Demands Hierarchy' (appendix 5) has reviews the importance of 'safety needs as being a lower level demand of a human for setting off inspiration. As seen in the pyramid shared in appendix 3, we can see exactly how 'the requirement to feel safe as well as safe' goes to the second degree of requirements. Prior to a worker can be made to create emotionally, he needs to have his 'Physical 'as well as 'Safety' needs satisfied. This indicates that unless the employees are made to really feel protected about their present work status in Renova Toilet Paper Escaping The Commoditization Trap Abridged they may not get to 'Self-Fulfillment'. (King, 2009).

SWOT Analysis for Renova Toilet Paper Escaping The Commoditization Trap Abridged Case Study

Effects of Analysis.

The OB analysis has taken a look at numerous theories to understand just how to manage the present situation handy. The adhering to three choices have actually been recommended to assist Lewis take care of the organizational obstacles in the advertising and marketing division. Each of these options has been recommended for alleviating the change required to bring the advertising and marketing department in line with the needs of the market as well as for making the cultural change that would adhere to as soon as the present leader leaves.

Integration of advertising and marketing functions. Separating Adverting and Production functions. Integration of Advertising And Marketing with Operations.

Evaluation of Alternatives.

Integration of Advertising And Marketing & Advertising Functions: The internal advertising and marketing agency of Renova Toilet Paper Escaping The Commoditization Trap Abridged is currently stamina for the company in terms of conserving up on expenses associated with advertising and marketing and also promo. Given that no new recruitment has been done after Bridget Cole's separation with the reporting line being straight designated to Krasnow for the advertising feature, this is a favorable possibility for incorporating the marketing and advertising features. Judith Shapiro that has earlier been spoken with by Lewis during the earlier merger days has knowledge in business-to-business marketing along with agency and retail advertising experience. As soon as Krasnow leaves, Lewis can employ Shapiro as an EVP for advertising and marketing to manage both advertising and marketing features.

The advantage of this strategy is that it will integrate the two functions while minimizing the demand for hiring an additional resource for advertising. Lewis would certainly be heading the advertising and marketing division and also in any type of case her substitute would be required for the present role that she is performing. The negative aspect of this alternative is that exterior hiring may bring about resentment from inner workers who might be looking at the placement of EVP after Lewis takes control of Krasnow's placement.

Dividing Adverting and Production: Provided the competitive stress as well as excellent quality job required from the ad agency, it is advised that Lewis needs to permit the manufacturing device to be a separate function from the advertising and marketing unit. Given that the majority of ad agency had these two features as different systems, it makes even more feeling to comply with the norm. Both features might be able to focus on their core triggers more successfully. However, the negative aspect of this approach would certainly be that additional expenses would need to be birthed for establishing different manufacturing features. A manufacturing head may have to be worked with which might raise overheads for the organization.

Assimilation of Marketing with Operations: Considering that Lewis is currently taking care of the advertising and marketing and also procedures departments at the same time; it makes good sense to incorporate the two functions because she has actually been efficiently caring for both ends. The truth that both departments already have significant distinctions over allotment of sources recommends that this integration may be able to bring about harmony particularly as Lewis would certainly be heading both ends.However there are numerous disadvantages of this step especially as it would put too much worry over Lewis's shoulders. The fact that Lewis needs to adapt her administration design for the advertising department suggests that these 2 divisions would certainly be culturally varied. Lewis may not be able to apply one type of management style to both departments which might result in ineffectiveness in either one of the 2 functions.


An assessment of the three options shows that combination of advertising and operations would not be a feasible action as a result of the substantial differences in between both divisions despite the fact that presently Lewis is taking care of both. While splitting up of the production function may have been a favorable step for the marketing division, the truth that it would suggest placing a 3rd function under Lewis's wing indicates this ought to be prevented also. The assimilation of the advertising and marketing division is the very best choice in terms of getting the ideal results from the division. An action prepare for this choice is talked about below.

Action Strategy.
Lewis will take over the role of EVP Marketing after Krasnow leaves.

Marketing and advertising functions would certainly be combined.

Judith Shapiro will certainly be hired to take Lewis's location as SVP of advertising and marketing.

Production function will stay part of advertising under marketing feature.

Lewis will certainly divide herself from operations.

A democratic leadership style with employee empowerment will be used in marketing division.

Open door plan and also emphasis on cross departmental communication will certainly be targeted at removing disharmony.

Backup plan.

If the assimilation does not exercise as planned, a backup strategy would certainly comply with which would certainly separate the production function from the advertising and marketing feature to lower the load on the SVP of marketing and advertising. In case Judith Shapiro does not get worked with, Lewis will certainly be heading the marketing department without an SVP. Because case the production function will certainly be divided by putting it under an SVP manufacturing.