Renova Toilet Paper Escaping The Commoditization Trap Abridged Case Study Solution


Home >> Chicago Booth >> Renova Toilet Paper Escaping The Commoditization Trap Abridged >>

Renova Toilet Paper Escaping The Commoditization Trap Abridged Case Study Analysis

Background and Facts

Renova Toilet Paper Escaping The Commoditization Trap Abridged a workplace supplies retailer for tiny and average sized businesses has lately been involved in preparing for a merging with its rival Residence Deport, which has influenced efficiency degrees in departmentswith the senior supervisor associated with legal problems put forth by the government Profession Commission. With the Advertising Head advancing the information of his departure from the company in one year, Jeannie Lewis, the present head of operations has actually been asked to take the role in the future. With challenges in the kind of a potential cultural adjustment and also reduced staff member morale, the company needs a total reengineering effort at the advertising and marketing division.

Trouble Statement
Porter's 5 Forces Analysis
The potential social change at the marketing division of Renova Toilet Paper Escaping The Commoditization Trap Abridged is raising unpredictability in the working environment causing different obstacles for the Jeannie Lewis who would certainly be replacing the head of the division in one year. nalysis

PEST analysis

Political Factors: Political factors play a significant function in influencing calculated choices since Stapes Inc. had to desert its strategies of combining with Office Deport after the Federal Profession Payment's treatment in the process. Offered the fact that the store has a global presence with branches in UK, USA, Canada and also Germany, political factors in each of these countries might be able to affect performance or strategic objectives. Federal Profession Commission's antitrust suit against the merger used up important time of the company's senior administration recommending that 'political' factors can have major implications for an international business.

Economic Factors: Economic factors such as the development of local business in the global situation recommend that Renova Toilet Paper Escaping The Commoditization Trap Abridged is growing in an atmosphere where there is prospective growth of organisations. Along with this, truth that shop customers are primarily seeking office products for office suggests that the market has a climbing trend of business owners as well as home based companies.

Social factors: Social trends in the economic climate show that consumers are searching for benefit as well as attractive prices. Marketing research shows how the customer for Renova Toilet Paper Escaping The Commoditization Trap Abridged does not have recognition concerning discovering services which can provide a mix of benefit as well as low costs.

Technical factors: Innovation plays an important duty in Renova Toilet Paper Escaping The Commoditization Trap Abridged's business approach especially as the company is piloting Technology centers which would certainly use innovation sales as well as support in the form of memory upgrades, peripheral setups. (Summary of INSECT in appendix 2).

OB Issues as well as Symptoms.

Several underlying Business Behavior concerns can be seen in Renova Toilet Paper Escaping The Commoditization Trap Abridged's case as highlighted in this section.

Concerns about cultural change: There is concern regarding a social adjustment that would certainly occur once Todd Krasnow leaves from his placement as the Exec Vice President of Advertising And Marketing with the majority of the team member currently showing discontent over this potential move. This expected change has created stress and anxiety in the work environment which has been paired with the previous stress and anxiety of preparing the firm for a prospective merger with Home Deport.
Pest Analysis
Difficult Task Atmosphere for Newcomers: There is lack of employees that can match the difficult setting of a busy organization. Not only does this lead to trouble in finding the right people, it places stress and anxiety on brand-new hires as can not hold up against the rate as well as pressure that the company anticipates them to birth.

Double Reporting Lines: Newcomers discover this business society cumbersome as well as challenging to handle specifically as populated line partnerships are implied to be weak as a whole and also unbiased setting as well as efficiency examination is still done by the solid line supervisor. This suggests that newbies might shed clearness regarding their respective functions as well as goals especially as populated line reporting does not keep them in straight communication with the strong line managers.

Resentment From Cross Departmental Hiring: Krasnow's choice to make Lewis his follower instead of Bridget Coles even though it had actually been hypothesized that the last would take Krasnow's setting came as an impact to her spirits. Lewis might have been capable as well as suitable for the work however the truth that Kransnow's separation would make Coles a straight record to Lewis may have been the factor for Coles' resignation from services.

Concern & Task Insecurity: Concern and insecurity can be determined as two major issues that Lewis would certainly be dealing with particularly as the merger has actually now be terminated and also 2 senior execs of the advertising division would certainly be leaving. The whole obligation of the division would be falling on Lewis's shoulders that would not simply be in charge of brining concerning a social change yet would certainly also have to verify herself in her brand-new function.

Incompatible Administration Style of Leader: Lewis's management style and also its incompatibility with the advertising department's duty can also be seen as an OB difficulty especially as she has actually been used to handling problems in the procedures division where employees are educated to concentrate on processes and also obtain them right. The advertising and marketing division on the other hand can be seen as a team of people who are used to being nurtured by Krasnow that focused much more on outcome than processes.

Interdepartmental Arguments: Interdepartmental arguments in between three divisions, advertising, merchandizing and also procedures specifically over the appropriation of the advertising mix can be recognized as an additional OB issue. Although the marketing division does not share the same vision as the other 2 divisions pertaining to the aloocation of the marketing mix twoards promos as well as advertsing, the merchandizing and procedures departments do not concur over the advertising mix appropriation amongst each other either.

Fragmentation in Advertising And Marketing Department: Disintegration in between the marketing and advertising divisions can be determined as an additional OB concern which can require additional interest. The reality that the advertising and marketing sections in the marketing department are detached is protecting against both divisions from gaining from each other's experience and knowledge. Assimilation of advertising with merchandising as well as procedures would certainly come to be harder if the advertising and marketing department itself is degenerated which can be one more potential OB problem.

Renova Toilet Paper Escaping The Commoditization Trap Abridged Analysis

Various concepts have actually been utilized to clarify the situations to obtain additional quality concerning the situation at hand.
Swot Analysis
McGregor's Concept X & Y: According to Douglas McGregor's Concept X, many managers think that staffs are easy as well as careless, have little aspiration and also stand up to adjustment. The scenario at Renova Toilet Paper Escaping The Commoditization Trap Abridged is not entirely complying with Concept X, it can be seen that new hires are discovering this environment rather demanding which might at some point lead to a greater inclination of the monitoring towards Concept X. Also while examining Lewis's management style, concept X might have been suitable in the procedures division to some degree yet the Advertising and marketing department would need dependence on Theory Y in order to get the creative thinking and also creativity from the teams.

Tuckman's Teamwork Theory: As far as Lewis's problem regarding bringing consistency in between the advertising and also advertising and marketing division is worried, this would at first lead to clash as gone over by Bruce Tuckman in his 'Team effort Theory'. By combining the advertising and marketing and advertising department's work, there may be the same preliminary separate which could lead to the second stage of 'storming' where the teams test one an additional.

When people are provided with adjustment, they get in stage one and also so there may be feelings like sadness, uncertainty, frustration, rage, fear, rejection and disorientation.The circumstance at the advertising and marketing department of Renova Toilet Paper Escaping The Commoditization Trap Abridged is similar so Lewis can obtain comfortable with the idea that it is not amazing behavior. It is throughout this stage that Lewis will have to provide support to the department so that they can find a feeling of direction. It can be seen exactly how Krasnow has currently made this change much easier by making Lewis obtain entailed in the department a year before his actual departure.
Vrio Analysis
Maslow's Need hierarchy: The OB problem related to instability at the work environment has been set off first of all by the modification in monitoring and also secondly by the fact that the merger will no longer be launched. Abraham Maslow in his Theory of 'Requirements Power structure' (appendix 5) has goes over the relevance of 'security needs as being a reduced degree requirement of a human for activating inspiration. As seen in the pyramid shared in appendix 3, we can see exactly how 'the demand to feel protected and untouched' is at the second degree of requirements. Before a worker can be made to create mentally, he requires to have his 'Physical 'and 'Safety and security' requires met. This indicates that unless the employees are made to really feel safe about their existing work condition in Renova Toilet Paper Escaping The Commoditization Trap Abridged they might not get to 'Self-Fulfillment'. (King, 2009).

SWOT Analysis for Renova Toilet Paper Escaping The Commoditization Trap Abridged Case Study

Ramification of Analysis.

The OB analysis has actually checked out various concepts to comprehend exactly how to cope with the existing situation available. The following three choices have been recommended to aid Lewis deal with the organizational challenges in the advertising division. Each of these options has actually been proposed for relieving the shift needed to bring the advertising and marketing department in accordance with the demands of the market and for making the cultural modification that would certainly adhere to when the existing leader leaves.

Integration of advertising and marketing functions. Separating Adverting and also Production functions. Integration of Advertising with Operations.

Examination of Alternatives.

Assimilation of Marketing & Marketing Functions: The internal advertising company of Renova Toilet Paper Escaping The Commoditization Trap Abridged is already toughness for the organization in regards to conserving up on overheads related to advertising and promotion. Because no brand-new employment has been done after Bridget Cole's departure with the coverage line being directly assigned to Krasnow for the marketing function, this is a favorable chance for integrating the advertising and marketing functions. Judith Shapiro who has earlier been talked to by Lewis throughout the earlier merger days has know-how in business-to-business advertising and marketing along with agency as well as retail marketing experience. When Krasnow leaves, Lewis can employ Shapiro as an EVP for advertising to manage both marketing and advertising features.

The advantage of this method is that it will certainly incorporate both features while minimizing the demand for working with an extra resource for advertising and marketing. In addition to this, Lewis would certainly be heading the marketing department and also regardless her replacement would certainly be needed for the existing function that she is performing. The drawback of this choice is that external hiring may bring about resentment from inner personnel that might be considering the placement of EVP after Lewis takes over Krasnow's placement.

Separating Adverting and Manufacturing: Provided the competitive stress as well as high quality work required from the marketing company, it is advised that Lewis must enable the production system to be a separate feature from the marketing unit. Considering that a lot of marketing firms had these 2 functions as different units, it makes more sense to adhere to the standard.

Integration of Marketing with Procedures: Considering that Lewis is currently taking treatment of the advertising and operations departments simultaneously; it makes feeling to integrate the two functions considering that she has actually been efficiently taking care of both ends. The fact that Lewis has to adapt her management design for the advertising department suggests that these 2 divisions would be culturally varied.


An assessment of the 3 alternatives shows that assimilation of advertising and marketing and procedures would certainly not be a feasible step because of the huge distinctions between both divisions although that presently Lewis is handling both. While splitting up of the production feature might have been a positive relocation for the advertising and marketing division, the fact that it would suggest placing a 3rd feature under Lewis's wing implies this must be avoided also. The assimilation of the advertising division is the very best choice in terms of getting the optimum results from the department. An action plan for this choice is talked about below.

Action Strategy.
Lewis will take control of the duty of EVP Advertising and marketing after Krasnow leaves.

Advertising and Marketing features would certainly be combined.

Judith Shapiro will be employed to take Lewis's place as SVP of marketing and advertising.

Production feature will certainly continue to be part of advertising and marketing under marketing feature.

Lewis will separate herself from operations.

A democratic management design with employee empowerment will certainly be used in advertising and marketing division.

Open up door policy as well as focus on cross departmental communication will certainly be targeted at removing dissonance.

Contingency strategy.

If the assimilation does not exercise as planned, a backup strategy would adhere to which would separate the manufacturing feature from the advertising and marketing function to decrease the load on the SVP of marketing and advertising. In case Judith Shapiro does not get worked with, Lewis will certainly be heading the advertising division without an SVP. Because case the production feature will certainly be divided by placing it under an SVP manufacturing.